Art Market
Jenny Saville Becomes Most Expensive Living Female Artist at £67.3 Million Sotheby’s Sale
Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

After an extended, five-person battle at Sotheby’s London Friday, became the world’s most expensive living female artist when her painting Propped (1992) sold at the house’s New Bond Street salesroom for £9.5 million ($12.4 million). The work was from the portion of the sale dedicated to pieces from the management consultant and collector David Teiger that grossed a total of £35.9 million ($47 million). Combined with the contemporary sale that followed, Sotheby’s brought in a total of £67.3 million on the evening, ahead of the low estimate of £53.2 million ($69.3 million).
Coming just six lots into the evening, the vigorous brawl for Saville’s large painting set the tone for the rest of the night, when active bidding in the room contributed to a 100% sell-through rate for the Teiger collection and 81% sell-through rate by lot for the contemporary sale (Christie’s notched an 85% sell-through on Thursday night).

Top lots

Adrian Ghenie, Boogeyman, 2010. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Adrian Ghenie, Boogeyman, 2010. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

  • Jenny Saville’s Propped (1992) hammered at £8.25 million. It was won by the bidder on the phone with Sotheby’s head of Impressionist and Modern Art Helena Newman after a protracted bidding war with North and South America chairman Lisa Dennison. The result more than doubled the painting’s high estimate of £4 million ($5.2 million). Europe head of Contemporary Art, Alex Branczik called the work “one of the undisputed masterpieces of the ,” and mentioned that he had seen the painting when it was exhibited in “Sensation,” the show of works from the collection of Charles Saatchi. It was acquired by Teiger in 2004 in a transaction arranged by Gagosian.
  • ’s Buffalo Station 1 (1997-1998) sold to the client on the phone with senior specialist for Impressionist and Modern Art, Samuel Valette, for a £6.5 million hammer—just above the £6 million low estimate. With fees, the total was £7.5 million ($9.8 million).
  • ’s Bogeyman (2010) sold to the client on the phone with Dennison for a £4.1 million hammer—well above the high estimate of £3 million. With fees it came to £4.8 million ($6.3 million), a high price, but short of the artist’s record, which was achieved at the Christie’s sale during Frieze in October 2016, when Nickelodeon (2008) sold for £7.1 million ($9 million).
(Pre-sale estimates do not include Sotheby’s premium, which is 20% on works between £200,000 and £3 million, and 12.9% on works above £3 million.)
Peter Doig, Buffalo Station I, 1997–98. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Peter Doig, Buffalo Station I, 1997–98. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

The evening’s total was enough to beat out Sotheby’s equivalent sale last year, when the contemporary sale and the Italian sale totaled £68.7 million (just under $91 million). This year, works that would have made up a standalone Italian sale were woven into the contemporary sale, and the results were mixed: would-be pricey works by and could not find bidders and were bought in. Other works by artists with usually-deep demand like and , were captured with a single bid on the phone, presumably by the guarantor.
But, for the most part, auctioneer Oliver Barker was able to conjure healthy bidding on a fair amount of lots, setting a record not only for Saville but also for , when a work from the Teiger collection sold to a phone bidder for a £460,000 hammer, or £574,000 ($753,427) with fees. And the salesroom maintained an active feel until the auction’s end.
Thaddaeus Ropac, the Austrian dealer who has galleries in London, Paris, and Salzburg, attributed the buoyant mood to the momentum generated by the works once owned by Teiger, who died in 2014 and spent many years as a trustee of the Museum of Modern Art in New York.
Andy Warhol, Joseph Beuys (Diamond Dust), 1980. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Andy Warhol, Joseph Beuys (Diamond Dust), 1980. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Kai Althoff, Er Will Alles Sehen, 2002. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Kai Althoff, Er Will Alles Sehen, 2002. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

“This was great material, and there was very quick, active bidding,” said Ropac, who personally put up his paddle during a number of lots, successfully winning an portrait of for a £660,000 hammer, or £802,000 ($1,000,000) with fees. (Ropac began representing Beuys’s estate in April of this year.) The dealer praised Teiger for his ability to get works from sought-after artists in their prime.
“He was able to get first choice from dealers because he gave so often to MoMA—I sold to him all the time,” Ropac said. “And that’s what made the sale.”The sale at Sotheby’s came just after the 20th Century and Contemporary Art Evening Sale at Phillips, which achieved £20.2 million ($26.4 million).

Top lots

Gerhard Richter, Hände, 1963. Courtesy of Phillips.

Gerhard Richter, Hände, 1963. Courtesy of Phillips.

  • Christopher Wool’s Untitled (P271) (1997) was won by the London dealer Inigo Philbrick at a hammer of £3.2 million. Philbrick beat out Phillips’s Tamila Kerimova, the head of the day sale. With fees, the price was £3.8 million ($4.9 million).
  • ’s Perch and Twirl (1973) sold for a £2.6 million hammer, or £3.1 million ($4.1 million) with fees. It went to the client on the phone with Jane Yoon, international specialist and Phillips’s regional director for Korea.
  • ’s Hande (1963) narrowly missed its low estimate of £2 million, hammering at £1.7 million, or £2 million ($2.6 million) with fees. There was just one bid on the lot, from the bidder on the phone with Miety Heiden, Phillips’s deputy chairman and head of private sales.
Joan Mitchell, Perch and Twirl, 1973. Courtesy of Phillips.

Joan Mitchell, Perch and Twirl, 1973. Courtesy of Phillips.

Banksy, Girl With Balloon, 2006. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

Banksy, Girl With Balloon, 2006. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.

But the evening’s true fireworks didn’t come until the very end of both sales, at Sotheby’s, when ’s iconic Girl With Balloon (2006), which was installed beside the back rostrum, came up for sale. The work attracted feverish bidding in the room and on the phones, racing past its high estimate of £300,000 to hammer at £860,000, or just over £1 million ($1.3 million with fees). As the gavel slammed, a siren rang out through the salesroom and everyone stood stunned as the Banksy canvas slid through the frame that it was contained in and emerged underneath—but shredded.
Confusion erupted throughout the salesroom, but it seems that the art world’s biggest prankster concocted a scheme in which his work would get destroyed as soon as it was sold. The spray painted work of the girl with a red balloon, acquired directly from the artist, came in what the catalogue called “the artist’s frame”—a frame that was oddly thick for such a small work of . A source at Sotheby’s, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said that the Banksy camp had insisted on securing an unusually high number of seats for the sale. Some onlookers reported seeing one of these people with a device in his hand after the shredding happened, and that he was detained by security as he tried to leave.
“We have not experienced a work spontaneously shredding after it sells for a million pounds,” Branczik said at the press conference.
He absolutely denied any knowledge that such an act was coming.
“We got Banksy’d,” he said.
The salesroom calmed down for long enough that a from the Teiger collection that went unsold earlier in the evening could get brought back out for another go. Branczik jousted with senior specialist Martin Klosterfelde and the work eventually sold for £370,000 ($485,018) with fees, well below the original £800,000 low estimate.

Takeaway

Despite the record-breaking Saville, Sotheby’s wasn’t able to match the £84.6 million ($109.4 million) haul brought in by Christie’s the night before—even though the rival house had a number of high-profile passes. Securing the Teiger collection was a coup, but Sotheby’s has still struggled to secure the big-fish consignments, like the that sold for £19.9 million ($26 million) on Thursday, that continue to put Christie’s Post-war and Contemporary Art department on top.
Oh, and one more: the Banksy stunt was an inside job.
Nate Freeman is Artsy’s Senior Reporter.

Cover image: Jenny Saville, Propped, 1992. Courtesy of Sotheby’s.