Who Actually Shot Richard Prince’s Iconic Cowboys?
Norm Clasen, Sunset Chase, Riverton, WY, 1985. Courtesy of the artist.
Four decades ago, an unknown, Colorado-based photographer created images that inadvertently led to widespread controversy and multi-million dollar auction prices, not to mention a new wave of nicotine addiction. Just south of Sunset Boulevard, M+B Photo is finally giving this body of work its closeup. Norm Clasen’s “Titled (Cowboy)” series is on view in a gallery setting for the first time, though his images already have a confirmed spot in art history, thanks to their later, high-profile appropriation by the artist
One photograph, Sunset Chase, Riverton, WY (1985), depicts a cowboy riding into an orange sunset, whipping a lasso around his head. In a photograph shot in Seymour, Texas, a horse leads its vest-clad, brimmed hat-wearing rider through splashing water. In general, Clasen’s work offers glimpses of stereotypical scenes most frequently associated with Hollywood, or at least Spaghetti Westerns.
In the late 1970s, the famed Leo Burnett advertising agency hired Clasen to scout locations for a new campaign it was executing for Marlboro cigarettes. The original photographer dropped out of the project, so Clasen did a test shoot. The agency liked his work enough to hire him instead. The cigarette company, which had previously focused on women smokers with its “Mild as May” slogan, wanted to rebrand itself as rugged, masculine, and strong. Advertisements would feature ranchers, or actors posing as ranchers—the ultimate symbols of the (mythical) tough, independent, American (white) male.
Clasen believes he got the job because of his easy rapport with the cowboy subjects and the Western landscape itself. “I’ve lived there, I’ve been around them all my life, and I think that was coming through in all my photos,” he told Artsy.
The Marlboro Man campaign became one of the world’s most successful advertising ploys, running nationally from 1955 until 1999. The scheme helped the company become the #1 tobacco brand in the world in 1972, a position it’s retained ever since. Today, Marlboro rakes in $23 billion worldwide, selling products that are, of course, poisonous. (In fact, according to the L.A. Times, “at least four actors who have played [the Marlboro Man] in ads have died of smoking-related diseases.”)
Clasen, however, doesn’t smoke. “This was an opportunity to work for the most iconic campaign maybe in advertising history at this time,” he said. “I think anybody [who] saw that campaign over those years realizes it’s the only campaign of its time that created art for their ads.” He has no qualms about contributing.
In the mid-1970s, artist Richard Prince was working at Time Life Publications (now Time Inc.), combing through publications daily, when he began to see artistic potential in the Marlboro Man advertisements. Enamored with their simple, evocative depiction of an American archetype, he photographed the ads himself, enlarging them and cropping out the text. He rebranded the advertisement work as his own “Untitled (Cowboy)” series.
Prince never credited the original photographers (though, notably, the original advertisements hadn’t either). He eliminated the photographs’ commercial context and hung them in a gallery setting, making the images “art” in a way that Clasen’s work for Marlboro never was. In 2014, one of Prince’s appropriated works (which cribbed from a different Marlboro-commissioned photographer) realized $3.7 million at a Christie’s auction. Rephotographed images of Clasen’s original shots have garnered over $1 million.
About seven or eight years ago, after Prince’s auction prices had shot up, Clasen found out from a friend that Prince had lifted his work. “If you see somebody’s copied your work, there’s something deep down in you that says, ‘I’m the author of that,’” said Clasen. “Somebody took that work and rephotographed it. They’re not the ones that were out there lying with the rattlesnakes, the ants, the mosquitos.”
Whereas Clasen photographed in the service of a tobacco company, Prince photographed to provoke. When an audience views a photograph, they generally believe what they see—they trust the medium to depict reality, or at least they used to. Yet, Prince simply photographed an art-directed fiction, an image meant to sell a product.
In this way, “Untitled (Cowboy)” plays similar games as the “Untitled Film Stills” by
Yet, while Evans was dead by the time Levine appropriated his work, Clasen and his fellow Marlboro campaign photographers are very much alive. “There’s close to probably 17 images that have been copied,” Clasen surmised. “And it has always been a hollow feeling for me to know that that’s happening.”
Prince has been subject to copyright infringement complaints throughout his career, evidencing no attempt to alter his practice. In 2008, photographer Patrick Cariou filed suit against him for appropriating images from Cariou’s Yes Rasta book. A district court found Prince guilty in 2011, but an appeals court overturned the verdict in 2013. More recently, Prince took material from Instagram, and fine art photographer Donald Graham sued him; the case is pending.
Norm Clasen, Mission Ridge, Polson, MT, 1988. Courtesy of the artist.
Just miles from M+B Photo, the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) is exhibiting “Richard Prince: Untitled (Cowboy).” The show features two series from the 2010s that update Prince’s ideas from earlier decades. For a 2013 series, “Untitled (Original Cowboy),” he traveled to and photographed landscapes in the American West, such as Monument Valley, already made iconic by tourist snapshots and films. For the 2015–16 series “Untitled (Cowboy),” he returned to rephotography. Prince revisited old copies of Time magazine, using contemporary technology to amplify the images to sizes larger than 1980s technology had allowed.
“The goal was to take a deep dive exploration into the construction of the cowboy, the myth of the cowboy, and Prince’s career-long investigation of that mythology,” says Dhyandra Lawson, one of the show’s curators. Yesterday, following a conversation at the museum, Prince tweeted that “artists don’t sue other artists,” chiding his ripped-off detractors. His works, of course, won’t be for sale at the museum. Yet down the street at M+B, you can purchase Clasen’s works; a portion of the profits will benefit the APA (American Photographic Artists), going toward their copyright defense fund.
Alina Cohen is a Staff Writer at Artsy.
The Van Cleef & Arpels Frivole Collection
Sponsored by Van Cleef & Arpels